Can you sue your government for dirty air? In Indonesia, yes

Plus: the surprising origin of the term “Third World”

0 min read min left

Issue #410: In Indonesia, people who've been breathing toxic smoke since July are taking their government to court, and a judge just said they can go ahead. My intern Cadence Chua talked to Mongabay journalist Hans Nicholas Jong about the fires, the lawsuit, and the companies behind them. The full interview is coming to YouTube soon, and VIP subscribers get to see it first. Stay tuned!

Also this week: Why the lights are going out in Kurdistan. Eurovision, but in Asia. Almost half of Uruguayans say they'd give up democracy if... well, read on. Teenagers who fly 17 hours just to finish school. The surprising origin of the term "Third World," which turns out to be less proud than the legend. A world record for Buddhist stupas. A leading science journal that predicted the end of the world... for last Friday. And, so much more.

This newsletter has been edited by Jonathan Ramsay.

Indonesian court lets residents sue the government over toxic smoke from forest fires

Refresher: Forest and land fires have been burning in parts of Indonesia since July. The smoke, often called haze, has forced schools to close, disrupted flights, and reached neighboring Malaysia and Singapore. By late August, Indonesia's Health Ministry estimated that about 3.4 million people in seven provinces were at risk of respiratory infections because of the smoke.

As of November 5, the ministry recorded more than 425,000 cases of acute respiratory illness in those provinces. About 184,000 of those cases were in children aged nine or younger. What are these illnesses? Tiny particles in the smoke can reach deep into the lungs, trigger asthma attacks, and make heart and lung disease worse.

What happened
On November 11, a court in Pontianak, a city in Indonesia's West Kalimantan province, said a resident and three community groups could go ahead with their lawsuit against the government. They brought it as a class action, which means they can pursue the case on behalf of a wider group of people affected by the smoke. They say officials did too little to prevent the fires and failed to properly oversee the response. The court has yet to decide whether those claims are true. They also want officials to explain how they enforced rules on burning and what they did to protect people once the smoke reached their homes and schools.

It's been raining these past few weeks in the region, and that's helped clear some of the smoke. But the question remains: Who's responsible for protecting millions of people across Southeast Asia from these fires?

On Sunday, President Prabowo (finally) apologized for the haze. At the ASEAN summit in Manila, he said sorry to Singapore and Malaysia on behalf of the Indonesian government and people. He also said 16 firefighters had died fighting the fires and two helicopters had been lost. Last month, Singapore and Indonesia agreed to set up a joint task force to investigate companies linked to the fires. Singapore's PM Lawrence Wong now wants it to become an ASEAN-wide platform. Read this latest development as: Prabowo's apology was addressed to Indonesia's neighbors. At home, residents are taking his government to court.

Why this matters: For the groups bringing the case, breathing clean air is a basic right. In October, thousands of students protested across Indonesia, calling for stronger action on the fires. The class action asks what people can require of their government before the next fire season, while there is still time to reduce the risk.

Tell me more
The West Kalimantan chapter of an Indigenous non-governmental organization, AMAN, the Catholic Youth's regional chapter, civil society organization Perkumpulan Laman Punyung Indonesia, and Sisilius Rami, an individual activist, are suing the Indonesian government for negligence. Specifically, the plaintiffs have named President Prabowo and the West Kalimantan governor, among others, as defendants. They want the government to declare the fires a national disaster and for more resources to be allocated to the crisis. None of the defendants appeared in court on the first day of the hearing.

Protests also broke out in Jakarta in October, with protesters pushing the government to declare a national disaster. On November 10, thousands across the country rallied against the government's response to the fires and economic policies. In Yogyakarta specifically, there have been allegations of excessive force against protesters, with tear gas, water cannons, and rubber bullets used by police. The government has said that it would revoke the land rights of eight companies for their alleged part in the wildfires. At the COP31 summit in Antalya, a government official claimed that they are increasing the number of forest rangers and firefighters from 8000 to 70000 and improving early forest fire warning systems. They have also created a new government agency, the National Peatland and Mangrove Management Agency, for peatland restoration (which consists of rewetting dried-out peatlands).

Why is this a thing every year?
Palm oil, pulp, and paper are among Indonesia's top industries, and the slash-and-burn method is used by companies to clear vegetation for these plantations. Forest fires then occur, especially during the El Niño weather phenomenon (usually around this time of the year), when peatlands and forests are drier than usual, causing fires to spread easily. 

How successful could this lawsuit be?
It is too early to tell. Plaintiffs must now present evidence of their allegations to the court, and the case could even go to appeal courts afterwards, which might take years. Similar lawsuits in the past have yielded mixed results. One filed in 2016 against previous president Joko Widodo was successful at the district level but overturned in 2022. 

What could the role of the government be in a positive way
The forest fires were also disastrous in 2015, and back then, the government set up the Peatland and Mangrove Restoration Agency (BRGM), only to shut it down in 2024. It remains to be seen if the new agency will be more effective. Experts have said that the new agency needs to be given more authority and go beyond peatland restoration to managing it. Investigations into specific companies are another area of concern, instead of blaming indigenous smallholder farmers who have traditionally practiced burning in a sustainable way. 

Our conversation with Hans Nicholas Jong
What Happened Last Week intern Cadence Chua interviewed Hans Nicholas Jong, an Indonesian journalist at environmental news outlet Mongabay, to discuss the impacts of the fires, the lawsuit, governmental responses, his investigation into specific companies involved in the fires, and more. Speaking about the transboundary impact of the forest fires, he said, "Haze doesn't have an ID card, so it can travel wherever it wants." This interview will be published soon on YouTube (first for VIP subscribers). Stay tuned!

what else happened

*A note on sources: This section collects what news outlets around the world reported this week. I...

Please log in or subscribe for free to continue reading this issue.

Contribute to this issue

We could use your help to make this issue better. Take a look at the requests below and consider contributing:

  • Submit a piece of artwork for this issue
  • Submit a news, academic or other type of link to offer additional context to this issue
  • Suggest a related topic or source for future issues
  • Fix a typo, grammatical mistake or inaccuracy
Sources used in this issue

Below you'll find some of the sources used for this issue. Only sources that support "media embedding" are included.

Subscribe to What Happened Last Week

Each week, What Happened Last Week curates news and perspectives from Asia, Africa, and the Americas. The newsletter is written by Sham Jaff and focuses on stories that rarely receive sustained attention in Western media.

Read the free edition every week. VIP subscribers receive additional stories, recommendations on what to watch, read and listen, and more.